While exercise buffs have long used protein supplements to gain muscle, new research from McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, suggests one protein source in particular, whey protein, is most effective for seniors struggling to rebuild muscle lost from inactivity associated with illness or long hospital stays.
The study, published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, compared the impact of different forms of protein supplements on older adults, a growing population challenged by the loss of muscle and strength, or sarcopenia, which in turn can affect balance, gait, and the ability to perform the simple tasks of everyday life.
Researchers found that protein didn’t stop lean muscle loss caused by inactivity; however, whey supplements helped to rebuild muscle once the participants’ activities resumed.
“The important message here is that not all proteins are created equal. Whey is one of the highest-quality proteins and is ideal for older persons,” says Stuart Phillips, PhD, senior author on the paper and a professor of kinesiology at McMaster.
Researchers set out to compare the impact of whey vs collagen protein on muscle loss during periods of inactivity and then recovery.
Whey is considered a high-quality or “complete” protein, meaning it’s rich in all essential amino acids and is higher in leucine, one of the essential amino acids the body cannot make itself and therefore must derive from food.
Collagen peptides, by comparison, are much lower in their leucine content and lack or are low in essential amino acids.
For the study, researchers recruited men and women who were nonsmokers, didn’t have diabetes, and were between the ages of 65 and 80. One group of subjects consumed whey protein, the other collagen peptides, throughout the study.
For a five-week period, their diet was controlled, including a two-week time frame where their daily steps were restricted to 750 per day and their calorie intake reduced by 500 kcal per day, conditions that might mimic what older people often experience during a hospital stay.
Participants returned to normal activity levels during a one-week recovery period.
The team had predicted that the collagen peptide group would experience significantly greater muscle loss than the whey protein group, but that didn’t happen. Both groups lost the same amount of muscle.
“While we already know that complete protein sources are more potent for stimulating building processes we were surprised to discover that after two weeks of limiting steps among the participants, there were no apparent differences in muscle loss between the two groups,” says Sara Oikawa, lead author and a graduate student in the department of kinesiology at McMaster.
While protein was ineffective in mitigating muscle loss, researchers say, when participants returned to normal, muscle-building activity, the whey group recovered more skeletal muscle.
“When we consider measures that can be taken to help seniors as they age, it’s clear that whey is an important ingredient. Conversely, we should avoid collagen in formulations targeting older people,” Oikawa says.
In future research, Oikawa plans to focus on women specifically, who tend to experience greater difficulties in rebuilding strength.— Source: McMaster University
